Selling Structure
This article was originally published in Start Up
Executive Summary
Start-ups bent on determining the 3D structures of proteins are trying to figure out the best ways to package their capabilities and data for sale to drugmakers. Growing numbers of commercial and academic researchers are seeking information about proteins--in particular structural information that influences how these important actors of the body function, and how drugs may fit them. X-ray crystallography is the gold-standard way of getting structural information, and a number of start-ups are gearing up to use the method on a larger scale than ever before. They want to sell the data to drugmakers to use in drug discovery, or better yet, form alliances to obtain and leverage the data-whose value in quantity is as yet unproven. Business models are still evolving: early plans to create databases are fading as firms acknowledge it will take time to accumulate quantities of structures and drugmakers already deluged with data demand actionable information. Service models may suffice temporarily, but won't provide much return in the long-term. Small start-ups are focusing on determining structures of known targets, or new but simple ones, while other better-capitalized companies lay bigger plans: encouraging drugmakers to look at unknown targets and learn more broadly, or to utilize multiple crystals. All the firms are getting involved in screening as a means of lead discovery. Companies starting up in the field of structure-based drug design are competing in the marketplace not only with each other, but against the availability of public data, and other crystal-free methods of gaining information about proteins.
You may also be interested in...
Astex's Pyramid Scheme
Astex's latest deal with Schering further distances the firm from infrastructure-heavy structural biology players. Astex hopes that by applying its fragment-based approach to solving key discovery problems among a handful of much sought-after targets-rather than solving many target structures or offering its capability on a service basis-it can sign higher value deals and prevent itself from becoming a victim of the field's commoditization.
Practical Dealmaking in Discovery: The Structural Biology Case
Discovery dealmaking is by no means dead-but it's certainly been practicalized. In the last few months, one good example of a still interesting discovery area--high-throughput structural biology--has seen a flurry of dealmaking. But it's not yet frequent or rich enough to justify the venture valuations originally applied to them. And the deals themselves reflect the results-oriented conservatism of Big Pharma buyers.
Practical Dealmaking in Discovery: The Structural Biology Case
Discovery dealmaking is by no means dead-but it's certainly been practicalized. In the last few months, one good example of a still interesting discovery area--high-throughput structural biology--has seen a flurry of dealmaking. But it's not yet frequent or rich enough to justify the venture valuations originally applied to them. And the deals themselves reflect the results-oriented conservatism of Big Pharma buyers.